Sometimes, you need to perform a custom installation of an operating system (likely Linux) on a dedicated server. This happens, e.g., if the hoster does not support your preferred Linux distribution, or if you want to make some non-default decisions during the installation that are not easy to change later, like custom partitioning or other storage-related settings. For this use case, some hosters offer IPMI access. Using a Java applet, you can remotely look at the display of the server and send keystrokes and mouse input - even to the BIOS. Also, you can connect a local ISO image as a virtual USB CD-ROM and install an operating system from it.
The problem is - such virtual CD-ROM is unbearably slow if your server is not in the same city. The CD-ROM access pattern when loading the installer is all about random reads, because it consists mostly of loading (i.e., page faulting) executable programs and libraries from a squashfs image. Therefore there is an inherent speed limit based on the read access size and the latency between the IPMI viewer and the server. Even for linear reads, where the readahead mechanism should help, the virtual CD-ROM read speed is limited at something like 250 kilobytes per second if the latency is 100 ms. This is lower than 2x CD speed. If you are working from home using an ADSL or LTE connection, the speed would be even worse.
With distant servers or slow internet links on the viewer side, Linux installers sometimes time out loading their own components from the virtual media. In fact, when trying to install CentOS 7 over IPMI on a server located in Latvia, I always got a disconnection before it could load 100 megabytes from the installation CD. Therefore, this installation method was unusable for me, even with a good internet connection. This demonstrates why it is a good idea to avoid installing operating systems over IPMI from large ISO images. Even "minimal" or "netinstall" images are typically too large!
So, what are the available alternatives?
Having another host near the server being installed, with a remote desktop and a good internet connection, definitely helps, and is the best option if available.
Debian and Ubuntu offer special well-hidden "netboot" CD images which are even smaller than "netinstall". They are less than 75 MB in size and therefore have a better chance of success. In fact, even when not constrained by IPMI, I never use anything else to install these Linux distributions.
And it turns out that, if your server should obtain its IP address with DHCP, there is an even easier option: load the installer from the network. There is a special website, netboot.xyz, that hosts iPXE configuration files. All you need to download is a very small (1 MB) ISO with iPXE itself. Boot the server from it, and you will get a menu with many Linux variants available for installation.
There are two limitations with the netboot.xyz approach. First, to install some Linux variants, you do need DHCP, and not all hosting providers use it for their dedicated servers. Even though there is a failsafe menu where you can set a static IP address, some installers, including CentOS, assume DHCP. Second, you will not get UEFI, because their UEFI ISO is broken. For both limitations, bugs are filed and hopefully will get fixed soon.
A last-resort option, but still an option, would also be to install the system as you need it in a local virtual machine, and then transfer the block device contents to the server's disks over the network. To do so, you need a temporary lightweight Linux distribution. Tiny Core Linux (especially the Pure 64 port) fits the bill quite well. You can boot from their ISO image (which is currently only 26 MB in size, and supports UEFI) without installing it, configure the network if needed, install openssh using the "tce-load" tool, set the "tc" user password, and do what you need over ssh.
With the three techniques demonstrated so far, I can now say with confidence that slow IPMI virtual media will no longer stop me from remotely installing the Linux distribution that I need, exactly as I need.
The problem is - such virtual CD-ROM is unbearably slow if your server is not in the same city. The CD-ROM access pattern when loading the installer is all about random reads, because it consists mostly of loading (i.e., page faulting) executable programs and libraries from a squashfs image. Therefore there is an inherent speed limit based on the read access size and the latency between the IPMI viewer and the server. Even for linear reads, where the readahead mechanism should help, the virtual CD-ROM read speed is limited at something like 250 kilobytes per second if the latency is 100 ms. This is lower than 2x CD speed. If you are working from home using an ADSL or LTE connection, the speed would be even worse.
With distant servers or slow internet links on the viewer side, Linux installers sometimes time out loading their own components from the virtual media. In fact, when trying to install CentOS 7 over IPMI on a server located in Latvia, I always got a disconnection before it could load 100 megabytes from the installation CD. Therefore, this installation method was unusable for me, even with a good internet connection. This demonstrates why it is a good idea to avoid installing operating systems over IPMI from large ISO images. Even "minimal" or "netinstall" images are typically too large!
So, what are the available alternatives?
Having another host near the server being installed, with a remote desktop and a good internet connection, definitely helps, and is the best option if available.
Debian and Ubuntu offer special well-hidden "netboot" CD images which are even smaller than "netinstall". They are less than 75 MB in size and therefore have a better chance of success. In fact, even when not constrained by IPMI, I never use anything else to install these Linux distributions.
And it turns out that, if your server should obtain its IP address with DHCP, there is an even easier option: load the installer from the network. There is a special website, netboot.xyz, that hosts iPXE configuration files. All you need to download is a very small (1 MB) ISO with iPXE itself. Boot the server from it, and you will get a menu with many Linux variants available for installation.
There are two limitations with the netboot.xyz approach. First, to install some Linux variants, you do need DHCP, and not all hosting providers use it for their dedicated servers. Even though there is a failsafe menu where you can set a static IP address, some installers, including CentOS, assume DHCP. Second, you will not get UEFI, because their UEFI ISO is broken. For both limitations, bugs are filed and hopefully will get fixed soon.
A last-resort option, but still an option, would also be to install the system as you need it in a local virtual machine, and then transfer the block device contents to the server's disks over the network. To do so, you need a temporary lightweight Linux distribution. Tiny Core Linux (especially the Pure 64 port) fits the bill quite well. You can boot from their ISO image (which is currently only 26 MB in size, and supports UEFI) without installing it, configure the network if needed, install openssh using the "tce-load" tool, set the "tc" user password, and do what you need over ssh.
With the three techniques demonstrated so far, I can now say with confidence that slow IPMI virtual media will no longer stop me from remotely installing the Linux distribution that I need, exactly as I need.
No comments:
Post a Comment